by Susan
Can gratitude offer anything useful when life feels difficult?
Gratitude has been described as ‘a feeling of thankfulness, sometimes experienced as a deeper, more enduring emotion’. In the book ‘The Body Keeps the Score’, therapist Besser van der Kolk says that a gratitude practice can aid trauma recovery and help maintain good mental health.
When life feels challenging and difficult, any suggestion of gratitude might appear superficial and pointless. Isn’t it just ‘toxic positivity? Feeling pressure to be grateful can make us feel worse. Cliches like ‘smile, it might never happen’, or ‘think happy thoughts’ when the those suggesting this have no idea of our circumstances or emotions can feel dismissive.
Sometimes finding anything to be grateful for can seem impossible, even ridiculous.
A gratitude practice does not require us to ignore how we feel or to be positive all the time.
It’s not a substitute for therapy, nor about avoiding feelings or suppressing needs and pretending everything is ok. We are allowed to feel angry, sad, have mixed emotions or none. We especially don’t need to feel grateful for hurtful or traumatic events in our lives.
It’s important to acknowledge this, but we might also consider whether we can use gratitude to ‘soften the edges’ of hard times. As Dr Fleetwood Meade says, ‘Gratitude doesn’t erase suffering, but at times it can sit alongside it.’
Gratitude doesn't cancel out struggles or challenges but might possibly support us as we navigate these.
Any gratitude practice should feel like a gentle invitation, grounded in the present and not used to deny our reality. Trying to force it can feel inauthentic and contribute to feelings of failure or ‘falling short’. It should never be an expectation imposed by others, or even ourselves.
How can it help?
The Psychology Today article ‘The Neuroscience of Gratitude and Trauma’ describes a study comparing two groups: one used psychotherapy along with gratitude journalling, the other used psychotherapy alone. The study concluded more mental health improvement in the group that added gratitude writing.
We all go through tough times, some of these we may face alone, but often there are people or places we can reach out to for support. At times we might be encouraged or inspired by many things. Perhaps we find solace in reading, in music, in nature, in the mountains or by the sea. Sometimes the simplicity of a flower or a butterfly or a kind word or gesture can lift our hope and energy.
Keeping it simple.
We can begin a gratitude practice simply, allowing ourselves a mindful moment– even in the midst of tough times we can pause, take in something good: the breath, the light, the view, the quiet, a cup of tea, a feeling of safety, a message or some humour.
Actively looking for these little points of light (sometimes called ‘glimmers’) can affirm hope and help ease our path a little. We might share those ‘glimmers’ with others, reliving the enjoyment of a morning coffee, the movie we saw last night, the beautiful sunset.
Before sleep we might reflect on the day and think of one or two things we feel grateful for. Some people like to keep a gratitude journal, we can choose whatever feels right for us. If we can’t think of anything, the invitations below might help.
Do we feel gratitude for people who have made a positive difference in our lives?
Maybe those around us currently, or those who have helped us in the past? We might picture them and thank them. Friends or colleagues we’ve shared chats and laughter with? People who’ve taught us something – at school, practical life skills, to swim, to ride a bike or drive a car, to relax, to plant a garden, to cook or budget, to laugh, to grow in some way. We can express gratitude and strengthen our connection to others, giving thanks, little notes, kindness, emojis, high fives!
Which parts of our day to day life do we really appreciate?
We might consider the basics, our water, food, shelter, sleep, our health, our ability to have emotions, a sense of humour, to be creative, to earn money, to feed our families, to have fun, to use our imaginations, to see possibilities, to arrange a simple bunch of flowers. We might extend gratitude to our favourite artists, writers, comedians, musicians – the arts that add colour to our lives.
Gratitude can include appreciation for ourselves too.
We often credit others with positive qualities, but it can be good to recognise our own strengths and the effort it takes to show up despite difficulties. Taking a moment to appreciate ourselves can help build our confidence and self-esteem.
Can we be grateful for the various parts of ourselves – the playful part, the practical part, the worker, the trier? The friend in us who encourages and supports others?
Focusing on what we have in the present moment and valuing the ordinary in everyday life can remind us that we matter and have choices and agency in our own lives.
What matters most is whether practising gratitude benefits and supports us rather than feeling like a meaningless demand that society expects of us.
Happiful magazine says that ‘regular practice can relieve anxiety, foster hope and help us cultivate and maintain a positive outlook. It can shift from rumination and negative focus towards recovery – we can have moments of peace or contentment even amid strife. We can be struggling and acknowledge what we are grateful for at the same time.’
Taking a few minutes each day to check in with ourselves and to notice anything we are grateful for can lower stress, reduce overwhelm, aid mood and sleep and help regulate our nervous system. With practice we can intensify deep feelings of gratitude, as the brain releases ‘feel good’ neurotransmitters like serotonin and dopamine.
Why not try a gentle mindful gratitude practice today and see how it feels?